Academia Superiora

← All research

Data · IPEDS + BEA

Graduation rates: publics gained seven points, private nonprofits held

The median public four-year college now graduates 53% of its students in six years, up from 46%. Private nonprofits moved from 56% to 58%. The gains sit in large publics and research universities; small nonprofit colleges are as likely to have fallen as risen.

October 12, 2026 · 9 min read

Dozens of small robed figures on the tiers of a stone amphitheater

Our review of the latest IPEDS data reported one headline on graduation: rates rose at public four-year institutions and held at private nonprofits. This post breaks it down and checks it against state income and state funding.

Population: the 1,669 four-year institutions that reported a six-year bachelor’s graduation rate in all twelve IPEDS Graduation Rates releases from 2013–14 to 2024–25 (555 public, 1,050 private nonprofit, 64 for-profit). Each release reports the students who started full time, for the first time, six years earlier, so the releases cover the entering classes of fall 2007 to fall 2018. Figures are medians of institutions, not weighted by enrollment. Sector, size, state and Carnegie class are taken from each institution’s latest IPEDS directory record. Institutions that closed or stopped reporting are not in the panel.

The headline, year by year

The public median rose from 46% for the fall 2007 entrants to 53% for the fall 2016 entrants and stayed at 53% for the 2017 and 2018 classes. The private nonprofit median rose from 56% to 59% by the fall 2013 class, peaked at 59.5% for the fall 2015 class, and was 58% for the fall 2018 class.

Median six-year bachelor’s graduation rate, by entering class, %
44%53%61%200720092011201320152018

PublicPrivate nonprofit

Source: IPEDS Graduation Rates, releases 2013–14 to 2024–25 (entering classes of fall 2007 to fall 2018). 555 public and 1,050 private nonprofit four-year institutions that reported in all twelve releases.

A median can hide a split. Within institutions, 78% of the publics had a higher rate for the 2018 class than for the 2007 class, and 56% gained five points or more. Among private nonprofits, 54% rose and 40% fell; 36% gained five points or more and 24% lost five points or more. At the nonprofit median, the gains and the losses nearly offset: the median change was 1 point.

Where the public gains are

The table groups institutions by their 2021 Carnegie class. Public research universities gained the most, and most of them gained. Public baccalaureate colleges barely moved at the median. Among private nonprofits, the research and doctoral universities rose, and the baccalaureate colleges, the largest nonprofit group, fell slightly.

Median six-year graduation rate, fall 2007 and fall 2018 entering classes, and share of institutions whose rate rose, by 2021 Carnegie class
Carnegie classPublic: n, 2007 → 2018, rosePrivate nonprofit: n, 2007 → 2018, rose
Doctoral, very high research (R1)105: 66% → 74%, 90%39: 92% → 94%, 74%
Doctoral, high research (R2)90: 46.5% → 55.5%, 86%36: 74% → 77%, 89%
Doctoral/professional27: 44% → 51%, 81%130: 56% → 60.5%, 69%
Master’s224: 42.5% → 48%, 78%340: 53% → 56%, 60%
Baccalaureate92: 39.5% → 40%, 63%370: 57% → 54.5%, 40%
Special focus four-year4: too few to report128: 52.5% → 52%, 49%

Size tells the same story. Publics with 10,000 or more students (250 institutions) went from a median of 53% to 60%, and 85% of them rose. Publics under 5,000 students (187) went from 39% to 44%, and 67% rose.

At publics, the typical institution gained 4.5 to 6 points in every selectivity group. We grouped institutions by their admission rate for fall 2018, the last class in the data. Publics that admitted fewer than half their applicants (70 institutions) rose from 66% to 73.5%. Those that admitted 75% or more (242) rose from 46% to 52.5%. Publics with no admissions figures for that year (55) rose from 25% to 28%. Among private nonprofits, the most selective group (208 institutions admitting under half) moved from 78.5% to 79%, while those admitting 75% or more (327) moved from 53% to 57%.

The nonprofit plateau is a small-college pattern

Among private nonprofits, size separates the risers from the fallers. The chart shows the share whose rate was lower for the 2018 class than for the 2007 class. Nearly half of nonprofits under 1,000 students fell, and 37% fell by five points or more. Above 5,000 students, fewer than one in five fell.

Private nonprofits whose six-year graduation rate fell, fall 2007 to fall 2018 entering class, by enrollment size, %
Under 1,000 students (315)48%
1,000 to 4,999 (571)43%
5,000 to 9,999 (93)19%
10,000 to 19,999 (46)15%
20,000 and over (25)16%

Source: IPEDS Graduation Rates, releases 2013–14 and 2024–25; size from the latest IPEDS directory record. 1,050 private nonprofit four-year institutions that reported in all twelve releases.

By region, nonprofits in the Plains and the Southeast fell most often: 48% and 45% of them had a lower rate for the 2018 class. In New England and the Far West, 36% did.

Part of the small-college pattern is noise. A college with a few hundred students has a small entering class, and its rate swings from one release to the next. The median nonprofit under 1,000 students moved 6 points between consecutive releases; the median nonprofit with 20,000 or more moved 1 point. Comparing two single years overstates both rises and falls at small colleges.

Public gains by state

In the 33 states with at least eight publics in the panel, the median change for the 2018 class against the 2007 class ranged from +14 points to −2.5. Arkansas (10 institutions, +14) and Florida (11, +13) gained the most, followed by Alabama, Indiana, Kentucky and West Virginia at +11 each. California (32, +9) and Texas (30, +8) gained more than the median public, whose rate rose 5 points. New York (39, +3) gained less. Virginia (15, 0) started high, at 66%, and stayed there. Ohio (26, −1) and Washington (8, −2.5) fell.

State counts are small. A state with eight publics can move several points when one or two institutions change how they define their cohort, merge, or add a branch campus.

More students finish, and sooner

The four-year rate moved most. The median four-year rate at publics rose 13 points, from 21% to 34%, for the same entering classes. The six-year rate rose 7 points. The eight-year rate, which follows each class two years further, rose 5 points, from 50% for the fall 2005 class to 55% for the fall 2016 class. More students finish, and more of them finish in four years.

Median graduation and transfer-out rates, earliest and latest entering class in the data
MeasurePublicPrivate nonprofit
Four-year bachelor’s rate, fall 2007 → fall 2018 class21% → 34% (n 555)42% → 45% (n 1,050)
Six-year bachelor’s rate, fall 2007 → fall 2018 class46% → 53% (n 555)56% → 58% (n 1,050)
Eight-year bachelor’s rate, fall 2005 → fall 2016 class50% → 55% (n 546)57% → 60% (n 1,036)
Transfer-out rate, fall 2007 → fall 2018 class (reporters only)24% → 22% (n 345)23.5% → 23% (n 274)
Pell recipients, any award within 8 years, fall 2009 → fall 2016 class44% → 48% (n 550)51% → 53% (n 1,027)
Non-Pell students, any award within 8 years, same classes53% → 59% (n 550)61% → 64% (n 1,027)

The four-, six- and eight-year rates come from the Graduation Rates and GR200 surveys and count bachelor’s-seeking students who started full time. The Pell rows come from Outcome Measures, which counts all full-time students entering for the first time and any award at the same institution. Outcome Measures with a Pell split starts with the 2017–18 release, so it covers fewer classes. Only institutions with a transfer mission report transfer-out, which is why its n is smaller.

Pell students rose too, but the gap did not close

Pell recipients improved at both kinds of institution. The distance to other students did not shrink. At the median public, the gap between non-Pell and Pell award rates was 9 points for the fall 2009 class and 9 points for the fall 2016 class; it narrowed at 39% of publics. At the median private nonprofit it went from 6 to 9 points, and narrowed at 45%.

The mix of students also changed. At the median public in the panel, the share of undergraduates receiving a Pell grant fell from 38.4% in the 2013–14 College Scorecard file to 33.0% in 2023–24. At private nonprofits it fell from 35.6% to 30.3%. Pell recipients finish at lower rates on average, so part of each sector’s gain can come from a smaller Pell share rather than from better outcomes for the same students. These data cannot say how large that part is.

State income and state funding do not line up with the gains

We compared each state’s public median gain with two economic series. Per-capita personal income grew 63.2% from 2013 to 2024 in the median of the 40 states compared below (BEA, nominal; consumer prices rose 34.7% over the same years). State appropriations per FTE student at the median panel public rose from $5,410 in the 2013–14 IPEDS Finance release to $8,620 in 2023–24, up 59.3% against consumer price growth of 30.8%.

Across the 40 states with at least five panel publics, neither series tracks the graduation gain. The rank correlation with income growth was 0.01. With appropriation growth it was −0.29, slightly negative and too weak to tell apart from chance with 40 states.

Appropriations here are per full-time-equivalent student (full-time plus half of part-time enrollment), in nominal dollars. Some state figures reflect how institutions classify state money: the median Colorado public’s figure rose 436%, which is too large to read as a funding change. A state-level comparison also ignores the four to eight years between the money and the graduation.

What moves with graduation rates

Academia Superiora keeps a table of relationships between variables, computed across institutions for the 2023–24 IPEDS release (the fall 2017 entering class for the six-year rate) and partialled on undergraduate enrollment. A relationship there is a pattern across institutions. It says nothing about cause.

  • Among 616 public four-year institutions, the six-year rate moves with the full-time retention rate (coefficient 0.71, tier “direction”). The two measures describe different entering classes.
  • Across 1,994 institutions, the six-year rate moves against the share of undergraduates with Pell grants (−0.43, “direction”). The pattern is stronger inside some Carnegie classes: −0.72 among 216 arts and sciences baccalaureate colleges, −0.61 among 145 R1 universities and −0.52 among 307 larger master’s universities, all “direction”.
  • Among public four-year institutions, the six-year rate moves with SAT and ACT scores (0.59 to 0.68, n 376 to 422), moves against the admission rate (−0.38, n 536) and moves against the transfer-out rate (−0.31, n 485), all “direction”.
  • Within institutions over time, the six-year rate changes with the transfer-out rate in the opposite direction: −0.40 across 5,617 year-to-year changes at 923 private nonprofit four-year institutions (“direction”) and −0.22 across 4,647 changes at 523 public ones (“form”), 2014 to 2024, with each year’s common shift removed.
  • Instructional spending per student moves with the six-year rate in only one scope, arts, music and design schools: 0.58 among 49 schools (“form”), and 0.67 among 37 for instruction expense per FTE (“direction”). In the public, private nonprofit and all-institution scopes the table keeps no row for that pair. That means the pair did not pass the gate or was not among either variable’s twelve strongest neighbors. It does not mean there is no link.

The strongest rows, against the four-year, eight-year and Outcome Measures award rates, are left out. They count the same students’ completions at another time or in another survey.

What the data cannot tell

  • Why rates rose. IPEDS records outcomes, not the advising, scheduling, aid or admissions changes behind them.
  • Whether the panel is typical. It keeps only institutions that reported every year, so colleges that closed or stopped reporting are missing.
  • The outcomes of part-time and transfer-in students. The graduation rates here count only students who started full time, for the first time, at that institution.
  • Your institution. A national median says nothing about one college, and a small college’s rate can move several points when a few students change course.

What this means for planning

  • Compare your graduation rate with institutions of your size and Carnegie class. A national median mixes large publics that gained with small colleges that did not.
  • Track the four-year rate next to the six-year rate. At publics the four-year rate rose fastest, so peers who improved will show it there first.
  • Report the Pell and non-Pell rates together. A rising overall rate with a falling Pell share can leave the gap where it was.
  • If you are a small private college, read your own trend over several entering classes, not one. At the median college under 1,000 students, the rate moves 6 points between releases.

Every figure here comes from public data: IPEDS, the College Scorecard, the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the Bureau of Labor Statistics consumer price index. In Academia Superiora you can run the same comparisons for your own peer group, free.

Next postEnrollment grew two years in a row. Here is where.