Argument · Planning
Last year’s assumptions are the hardest thing to find
Every budget rests on assumptions made a year earlier. When the cycle starts again, they are buried in a deck, a spreadsheet or the memory of someone who has left.

A budget is a set of assumptions with a total at the bottom. First-year enrollment. Retention. The tuition rate and the aid that goes with it. Salary increases. Benefits. For a public institution, the state appropriation.
Each of these was agreed in a meeting, for a reason, with some evidence behind it. When the next cycle starts, the first useful question is simple: what did we assume last year, and what actually happened? It is often the hardest one to answer.
Where the assumptions end up
- In the final board deck, as a number without the reasoning.
- In a version of the budget model, often not the last one.
- In email threads between finance, enrollment and the provost’s office.
- In the head of the person who made the call.
The last one is the most fragile. Finance and institutional research offices are often small. When a CFO, a budget director or an IR director leaves, the reasoning behind a year of assumptions often leaves with them.
Why it matters
Without last year’s assumptions you cannot tell a forecast miss from a change in the world. If first-year enrollment came in below plan, was the yield assumption too high, or did the applicant pool shrink? The answer changes what you do next.
It also matters to the board. Trustees remember the rate they approved, and they will ask whether it worked. “We assumed yield would hold at last year’s level; it fell two points, mostly in out-of-state students” is the answer a board needs.
A simple fix: an assumption register
For each decision, keep a short list of the assumptions it depends on. For each one, record:
| Field | Example |
|---|---|
| The assumption | First-year yield holds at last year’s rate |
| The value | The rate used in the model |
| The source | Admissions funnel, three-year average |
| The owner | Dean of Admissions |
| When it was set | Finance committee, January |
| What happened | Filled in when census data arrives |
The last row matters most. When actuals arrive, from your own census or a year later from IPEDS, you fill it in. Next year’s planning starts from that list.
In Academia Superiora the approved decision and its assumptions stay on the case. The next year’s report starts from them, and the planning agent can compare them with what your peers have reported since then.
