Academia Superiora

← All research

Data · IPEDS + BEA

Two online universities, and a for-profit sector that closed, converted and consolidated

Private nonprofit enrollment rose 6.1% from 2013 to 2024, but two online universities added more than the whole gain. For-profits lost a third, mostly through closures, conversions and consolidated reporting.

October 12, 2026 · 9 min read

Small robed figures climb a broad flight of white stairs toward a round colonnade

Our first post on the 2024–25 IPEDS collection reported that private nonprofit enrollment rose 6.1% between fall 2013 and fall 2024, and that for-profit enrollment fell 32.1%. Both figures hold. This post breaks them down by institution, by how students attend, and by state.

Scope: every institution in the IPEDS Fall Enrollment survey, as in the first post. Enrollment is fall headcount. Sector is as each institution reported it that year. Same-institution comparisons follow the IPEDS unit ID, so a campus that merges into another unit ID, or starts reporting under a new one, appears as one exit and one entry. “Exclusively online” means students enrolled only in distance-education courses, as institutions report them to IPEDS.

Two universities account for more than the nonprofit gain

Private nonprofit enrollment rose by 255,000, from 4.17 million in fall 2013 to 4.42 million in fall 2024. Over the same years, Western Governors University (WGU) grew from 46,700 students to 210,200, and Southern New Hampshire University (SNHU) from 28,400 to 189,500. Together they added 325,000 students. That is more than the whole sector’s net gain.

Without these two universities, private nonprofit enrollment fell from 4.09 million to 4.02 million, down 1.7%. It was close to flat until 2019, fell through 2022, and has partly recovered since.

Fall enrollment by sector, index (fall 2013 = 100)
5684111201320152017201920212024

Private nonprofitPrivate nonprofit without WGU and SNHUPublicFor-profit

Source: IPEDS Fall Enrollment and Institutional Characteristics, fall 2013 to fall 2024, all institutions as reported each year; sector as reported each year.

The typical nonprofit did not grow. Of the 1,578 institutions that reported as nonprofits in both 2013 and 2024, 889 enrolled fewer students in 2024 and 688 enrolled more. The median change was −5.5%. Leaving out WGU and SNHU, their combined enrollment was flat (−0.1%).

The growth was online; campus enrollment fell

IPEDS asks each institution how many of its students take only distance-education courses. At private nonprofits that number more than doubled, from 549,000 in fall 2013 to 1.29 million in fall 2024. The number of students taking at least some courses in person fell by 484,000, or 13.4%.

Private nonprofit fall enrollment by mode, in thousands. Source: IPEDS Fall Enrollment, distance-education fields, fall 2013 and fall 2024; all private nonprofits as reported each year.
StudentsFall 2013Fall 2024Change
Exclusively online5491,288+134.6%
Some or all courses in person3,6163,133−13.4%
Exclusively online, without WGU and SNHU482894+85.6%
Some or all in person, without WGU and SNHU3,6093,127−13.3%

Two points follow from the table. The shift is not only WGU and SNHU: without them, exclusively online enrollment at nonprofits still rose 86%. And the in-person decline began before the pandemic. By fall 2019 the in-person count was already 3.38 million, 237,000 below 2013.

Which nonprofits grew

We grouped the institutions that were nonprofits in both years by their latest Carnegie class (2021 edition) and left out WGU and SNHU. Doctoral universities grew 8.1%, from 1.82 million to 1.96 million students at 217 institutions. The two largest doctoral gains were mostly online: Liberty University (+27,000, 85% exclusively online) and the University of the Cumberlands (+17,200, 62%). Research universities that enroll many graduate students also grew: Northeastern (+12,500), New York University (+12,200), Johns Hopkins (+9,300) and Columbia (+8,200). Master’s institutions fell 11.1%, from 1.17 million to 1.04 million at 369 institutions. Baccalaureate colleges fell 4.0%. Special-focus institutions were close to level (−1.3%).

Size tells a similar story. Institutions with 1,000 to 2,999 students in 2013 lost 6.1% of their enrollment in total; 64% of them shrank, and the median change was −9.9%. Institutions under 1,000 students grew 17.2% in total, but their median change was zero. A few small institutions built large new programs, such as Unity Environmental University (553 to 7,165 students, now almost all online).

Some large declines are reporting changes, not lost students. Indiana Wesleyan University’s online students moved to a new unit ID: the two IDs together grew from 15,000 to 16,500. The three Ana G. Méndez universities in Puerto Rico now report part of their enrollment under a new unit ID too, though their combined enrollment still fell by a third. In all, 334 nonprofit unit IDs that reported in fall 2013 did not report in fall 2024 (208,000 students in 2013), and 167 new ones appeared (113,000 students in 2024).

How for-profits lost a third

For-profit enrollment fell by 664,000, from 2.07 million at 3,517 institutions in fall 2013 to 1.40 million at 2,161 institutions in fall 2024. We followed each 2013 for-profit institution to its status in 2024.

What happened to the institutions that were for-profit in fall 2013. Source: IPEDS Fall Enrollment and Institutional Characteristics (sector, successor unit ID), fall 2013 to fall 2024.
Status in fall 2024InstitutionsStudents in fall 2013Share
Still for-profit, same unit ID1,574954,00046.2%
Stopped reporting, no successor named1,759603,00029.2%
Folded into another unit ID86334,00016.2%
Converted, then merged or stopped reporting65133,0006.5%
Same unit ID, now nonprofit or public3342,0002.0%

Closures are the largest part. The 1,759 institutions that stopped reporting include 146 ITT Technical Institute campuses and dozens of Art Institute, Argosy University and Everest College campuses. IPEDS covers institutions that take federal student aid, so a school that lost eligibility also leaves the count.

Conversions took 176,000 students out of the for-profit count, at 98 institutions. Not all of them survived the change. About 59,000 of those students were at 44 Everest and Altierus campuses that converted to nonprofit and later stopped reporting. Kaplan University has reported as Purdue University Global, a public institution, since fall 2018. Grantham University now reports as University of Arkansas Grantham. Northcentral University, several Bryant & Stratton College and Herzing University campuses, and Ultimate Medical Academy now report as nonprofits.

Consolidated reporting hides real shrinkage. University of Phoenix reported 286,000 students under 71 unit IDs in fall 2013 and 111,000 under 3 in fall 2024. That decline of 175,000 students is about a quarter of the sector’s net loss. A same-institution comparison does not see it, because most of the 2013 campuses no longer exist as separate units.

The for-profits that kept their unit ID grew, from 954,000 to 1.14 million students (+19.4%). Two things qualify that. Grand Canyon University, which IPEDS reports as for-profit, doubled from 55,500 to 113,300. And some survivors absorbed other campuses: the Colorado Springs unit ID of Colorado Technical University went from 2,000 students to 31,800. The median survivor shrank 1.5%.

By mode, for-profit students taking some or all courses in person fell 43.9%, from 1.20 million to 674,000. Exclusively online students fell 15.8%. In fall 2024, 52.0% of for-profit students studied only online.

The public recovery, state by state

Public enrollment fell to 13.68 million in fall 2022 and reached 14.53 million in fall 2024. Unlike the nonprofit gain, most of this recovery was in person: 735,000 of the 857,000 added students took at least some courses in person.

Public enrollment grew between fall 2022 and fall 2024 in 47 states and DC. It fell in Ohio (−1.2%), Pennsylvania (−0.2%) and Vermont (−2.5%). Over the full period, 18 of the 51 were at or above their 2013 level. Utah (+26.8%), Georgia (+16.6%), Arizona (+14.5%) and Indiana (+12.5%) grew the most. Alaska (−37.0%), New Hampshire (−23.9%), New Mexico (−23.6%) and Michigan (−20.4%) fell the most.

IPEDS counts online students in the state of the institution that enrolls them, wherever they live. Indiana’s figure includes Purdue University Global (45,600 students), a former for-profit. Some community colleges began awarding bachelor’s degrees in this period and were reclassified as four-year institutions, so a split of public enrollment into two-year and four-year mixes real change with reclassification.

Where population grew, in-person enrollment fell less

Because online students are counted at the institution’s home state, we compared states using in-person enrollment only: students taking some or all courses in person. We split the 50 states and DC into thirds by population growth from 2013 to 2024, using state population from the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA).

Change in in-person enrollment, fall 2013 to fall 2024, by state population growth
Fastest-growing third, public−10.8%
Fastest-growing third, private nonprofit−6.6%
Middle third, public−17.3%
Middle third, private nonprofit−9.0%
Slowest-growing third, public−23.4%
Slowest-growing third, private nonprofit−16.0%

Source: IPEDS Fall Enrollment distance-education fields, fall 2013 and fall 2024, students not enrolled exclusively online, 50 states and DC; BEA state population, 2013 and 2024. Fastest third: population +8.7% to +23.6% (e.g., ID, UT, FL, TX). Slowest third: −4.8% to +3.3% (e.g., IL, NY, PA, CA).

In-person enrollment fell in every group, and it fell least where population grew most. Across the 51, the change in public in-person enrollment moved with the change in population (Pearson r = 0.68, Spearman 0.68). For private nonprofits the link was weaker (r = 0.27), which fits institutions that recruit beyond their state. Growth in per-capita personal income separated states less than population growth did (r = 0.26 for all sectors).

This is a comparison of 51 states over one period. It shows that the two changes went together, not that population growth held enrollment up. Population here is all ages. Part of the in-person decline is students who now take every course online at the same institution, not students lost.

Small nonprofits that lived on tuition

We took the 1,487 private nonprofits with fewer than 3,000 students in fall 2013 that filed IPEDS Finance for fiscal year 2014. For each, we measured net tuition as a share of revenue, leaving out investment return. Of the 198 that relied on tuition for 90% or more of revenue, 64 (32.3%) no longer reported to IPEDS in fall 2024. In the other three bands the share was between 12.1% and 20.5%. Among those still reporting, enrollment change did not line up with tuition share.

Not reporting covers closure, merger and loss of federal aid eligibility; the enrollment file does not tell them apart. The tuition share is from a single fiscal year.

What moves with enrollment at private nonprofits

Academia Superiora’s relationship table correlates year-over-year changes within each institution, after removing the change that all institutions share in a given year. Three rows for private nonprofit four-year institutions (IPEDS sector 2) bear on this finding. All three are at the direction tier: the linear and rank coefficients agree in sign, and the pattern holds in at least three groups of institutions.

  • Instructional spending per FTE student changes with FTE enrollment, in the opposite direction: coefficient −0.66, over 17,275 institution-years at 1,760 institutions, 2014 to 2024. At public four-year institutions the same pair changes with a coefficient of −0.27, over 8,975 institution-years at 837 institutions, 2014 to 2024, at the form tier.
  • Net tuition revenue per FTE student changes with FTE enrollment, in the opposite direction: −0.48, over 17,253 institution-years at 1,757 institutions, 2014 to 2024.
  • Tuition dependency changes with undergraduate enrollment, in the same direction: +0.37, over 13,537 institution-years at 1,504 institutions, 2014 to 2023.

FTE enrollment is the denominator of both per-FTE measures, so the first two rows are partly arithmetic. When enrollment falls and spending falls more slowly, spending per student rises. What the first row adds is the sector contrast: per-student spending at private nonprofits moved more with enrollment than at publics (−0.66 against −0.27). That fits costs adjusting less to enrollment at private nonprofits, but the table does not show it directly. Two explanations fit the second row. Institutions that add students may discount more to do it, or the added students may be in lower-priced programs, such as online and part-time. Checking whether the discount rate changes with enrollment at the same institutions would separate the two. Tuition dependency is a share of total revenue, and at private institutions total revenue includes investment return, so a strong market year lowers it with no change in tuition.

A relationship is not a cause. “Changes with” means that in years when one measure rose at an institution, the other tended to move the stated way at the same institution.

What the data cannot tell

  • Where online students live. IPEDS counts them at the institution that enrolls them.
  • Why an institution stopped reporting. The successor field identifies some mergers; closures and loss of eligibility look the same.
  • Whether a sector label matches how an institution operates. IPEDS reports Grand Canyon University as for-profit.
  • How much each student weighs. These are headcounts: a part-time online student counts the same as a full-time residential one.

What this means for planning

  • Read sector growth with the largest institutions taken out. Two universities turned a nonprofit decline into a gain.
  • Compare exclusively online and in-person enrollment separately. At private nonprofits they moved in opposite directions for a decade.
  • When a peer’s enrollment jumps or disappears, check for a new unit ID or a merger before reading it as growth or loss.
  • If enrollment is falling, watch spending per student. At private nonprofits it has tended to rise in the years when enrollment fell.

Every figure here comes from public IPEDS and BEA data. In Academia Superiora you can run the same comparisons for your own peer group, free.

Next postWhere the graduate growth went