Academia Superiora

← All research

Data · IPEDS + BEA

Tuition kept pace with inflation. Net price fell behind it.

Published tuition rose about as fast as consumer prices over the decade; the median net price rose much more slowly. Most of the gap opened in 2021 and 2022, discounts grew, and every income band rose less than the average.

October 12, 2026 · 9 min read

Four small figures lean over a plan on a table beside a staked-out building site

Our overview of the latest IPEDS data found that published tuition at four-year colleges rose about as fast as consumer prices over the decade, while net price rose much more slowly: about three-fifths as fast at publics and half as fast at private nonprofits. This post takes that finding apart. It looks at when the gap opened, who received the discounts, how each income band moved, and how the price compares with local incomes and local costs.

Scope: four-year public and private nonprofit institutions, classified by the sector they reported in the last year compared. Medians are of institutions, not weighted by enrollment. Tuition and fees are for in-state students at publics. Net price is the cost of attendance minus grant aid, for first-time, full-time students who received grants; at publics it covers in-state students only. This post covers tuition through 2023–24 and net price through 2022–23. Academia Superiora has since added 2024–25 tuition and 2023–24 net price. Inflation is calendar-year CPI-U.

The headline, rebuilt

Median tuition and fees, and median net price, four-year institutions that reported in both years (tuition: 783 public, 1,262 private nonprofit; net price: 743 public, 1,171 private nonprofit)
MeasurePublicPrivate nonprofitCPI-U
Tuition and fees, 2013–14 to 2023–24$6,630 → $8,606 (+29.8%)$24,663 → $32,588 (+32.1%)+30.8%
Net price, 2013–14 to 2022–23$11,510 → $13,284 (+15.4%)$20,559 → $23,147 (+12.6%)+25.6%

In constant dollars, the median net price fell. The 2013–14 public median of $11,510 is $14,458 in 2022 dollars, so the 2022–23 median of $13,284 is 8.1% lower. At private nonprofits the drop is 10.4%, from $25,826 in 2022 dollars to $23,147.

Two choices move these figures. If each institution is classified by its 2024–25 sector instead of its 2022–23 one, the group becomes 787 four-year publics and their median net price grows 18.7%: 44 colleges, most of them public two-year colleges in 2022–23, join with lower starting prices. If each academic year is priced at the calendar year it ends rather than the one it starts, CPI-U rises 32.5% over the tuition period and 28.7% over the net price period. Neither choice changes the conclusion.

Most of the gap opened in 2021 and 2022

The ten-year comparison hides two different periods. In the same 719 four-year publics, median published tuition rose 23.6% from 2013–14 to 2020–21, while consumer prices rose 11.1%. Net price stayed close to inflation: by 2019–20 it was up 11.5%, against 9.7% for CPI-U.

Then inflation jumped. CPI-U rose 4.7% in 2021 and 8.0% in 2022, and colleges did not raise prices to match. Among the 719 publics that reported every year, median tuition in 2022–23 was 27.4% above its 2013–14 level and median net price 15.6% above, against 25.6% for CPI-U. Private nonprofits followed the same path.

Median tuition and fees and median net price, index 2013–14 = 100
971141322013–142015–162017–182019–202022–23

Public tuition and feesPublic net pricePrivate nonprofit tuition and feesPrivate nonprofit net priceCPI-U

Source: IPEDS Institutional Characteristics and Student Financial Aid, 2013–14 to 2022–23; BLS CPI-U, calendar years 2013–2022. Institutions that reported both measures in every year: 719 four-year publics and 1,139 private nonprofits, by sector reported in 2022–23.

“Kept pace” describes the endpoints. For most of the decade, published tuition ran well ahead of inflation. The inflation of 2021 and 2022 closed that gap, and left net price well below inflation.

Discounts grew, most at less selective privates

Most of the distance between sticker price and net price is the college’s own aid. We measure it for first-time, full-time students: institutional grant dollars per student, divided by published tuition and fees.

First-year institutional grants as a share of published tuition and fees, median institution
GroupInstitutions2013–142023–24Students with an institutional grant, 2023–24
Private, admit rate under 25%7239.5%46.0%54%
Private, admit rate 25–49%12739.1%46.0%88%
Private, admit rate 50–74%32447.8%58.0%99%
Private, admit rate 75% or more48646.7%57.0%99%
Private, open admission or no data14910.3%21.0%71%
All private nonprofit1,15843.7%53.4%97%
All public75518.1%30.6%64%

At the median private nonprofit, institutional grants now equal more than half of published tuition and fees for first-year students. The discount is deepest at colleges that admit half or more of their applicants. There, nearly every first-time student receives an institutional grant. The most selective privates discount less, and about half of their first-time students receive a grant.

At four-year publics, institutional grants grew from 18.1% to 30.6% of in-state tuition and fees. The median share of first-time students receiving one rose from 41% to 64%.

This approximates a first-year discount rate. It is not the NACUBO measure. At publics the denominator is in-state tuition, while grants also go to out-of-state students who pay more, so the public figure runs high. Selectivity is the fall 2023 admit rate. Institutional grants are from IPEDS Student Financial Aid for 2013–14 and 2023–24.

Every income band rose less than the average

Median net price by family income, 2013–14 to 2022–23 (nominal change; change after inflation)
Family incomePublicPrivate nonprofit
$0–30,000$8,780 → $9,257 (+5.4%; −16.1%)$16,563 → $17,569 (+6.1%; −15.6%)
$30,001–48,000$10,090 → $10,125 (+0.4%; −20.1%)$17,263 → $18,203 (+5.4%; −16.1%)
$48,001–75,000$13,161 → $12,902 (−2.0%; −22.0%)$19,555 → $20,722 (+6.0%; −15.6%)
$75,001–110,000$16,034 → $17,052 (+6.3%; −15.3%)$22,944 → $24,780 (+8.0%; −14.0%)
Over $110,000$16,906 → $19,412 (+14.8%; −8.6%)$26,529 → $29,115 (+9.7%; −12.6%)

At publics, the two middle bands barely moved in nominal dollars, and the top band rose 14.8%. At privates the three lower bands rose 5.4% to 6.1%, and the two upper bands 8.0% and 9.7%. After inflation, every band at every type of college pays less than in 2013–14.

Every band rose less than the 15.4% rise in the overall public median. Two features of the data can produce this pattern. First, the bands are fixed in nominal dollars. $30,000 in 2013 is $37,685 in 2022 dollars, so as incomes rise, families move into higher bands, which pay more. The shift shows in the counts. Among first-time, full-time students with federal aid at four-year publics, the share in the top band rose from 15.7% to 21.0%, and the share under $30,000 fell from 38.1% to 32.2%. At private nonprofits the top band went from 26.3% to 34.7%. Second, the overall median covers students with grants, while the bands cover students with any federal aid, loans included.

Against local income, net price fell

Per-capita personal income in the United States rose 49.4% from 2013 to 2022, computed from BEA’s state estimates. Across the 705 four-year publics with county income data, the median rise in county per-capita income was 45.8%, and the median institution’s net price rose 15.7%. Net price grew faster than county income at 15.6% of four-year publics and 10.1% of private nonprofits.

In 2022–23 the median four-year public’s net price equaled 19.6% of the median household income in its local area (Census ACS). Half of publics fell between 13.3% and 26.6%. At private nonprofits the median was 31.4%, and half fell between 22.1% and 40.9%.

Per-capita personal income counts every resident and includes investment income and government transfers, so it is not the income of students’ families. Students do not all come from the campus area. The local area is the campus ZIP code area for most institutions (536 of 751 publics) and the county for the rest, using ACS releases from 2021 to 2024. Counties where BEA reports zero income were excluded.

Place changes who looks expensive

A dollar does not buy the same everywhere. We divided each institution’s 2022–23 net price by its local price index (BEA regional price parities, refined by ZIP code; 100 is the US average), then compared quarters of institutions sorted by local price level.

Nominal public net prices show no steady pattern by place: $12,617 in the lowest-cost quarter, $13,015 in the highest, and up to $14,297 in between. In local purchasing power, the lowest-cost quarter is the most expensive, at $14,572, and the highest-cost quarter the least, at $12,034. At private nonprofits, nominal net price rises with local prices, from $21,786 to $25,938. Adjusted for place, it falls from $24,987 to $22,643.

The index uses the latest published vintage at or before each year. In the lowest-cost quarter of publics, 106 of 185 institutions use a value carried forward from an earlier year. Adjusting for place assumes students face local prices. That holds better for room and board than for tuition.

State money and public net price

At the median four-year public, state appropriations per FTE student rose from $5,351 in fiscal 2013 to $8,743 in fiscal 2022 (691 institutions with a value in both years). That is 63.4% in nominal terms and 30.1% after inflation. A per-student figure also rises when enrollment falls, and public enrollment fell over most of this period.

At 152 publics, state appropriations per FTE student grew less than CPI-U from fiscal 2013 to fiscal 2022; their median net price rose 20.3% from 2013–14 to 2022–23. At the 514 where appropriations per FTE student kept pace, median net price rose 15.4%. This compares two groups. It is not a test, because their states differ in many other ways. For public net price and state appropriations per FTE student, the relationship table gives no relationship found, in any cohort.

What moves with net price

Academia Superiora’s relationship table records which pairs of variables move together across institutions, after controlling for enrollment size. A relationship is not a cause. The rows below compare institutions in the 2023–24 survey year, where net price describes 2022–23 because the aid survey runs a year behind its release. Each is at the direction tier: the sign holds on ranks as well as values, and in at least three cohorts.

  • Four-year publics: net price moves with median earnings ten years after entry (r = 0.49, 796 institutions, 2023–24, direction tier). Higher-priced publics tend to have former students who earn more.
  • Four-year publics: net price moves with the share of out-of-state freshmen (0.42) and with the number of states represented (0.47), each across 648 institutions, 2023–24, direction tier. Higher-priced publics tend to enroll more students from other states.
  • Four-year publics: net price moves against the share of full-time, first-time students whose status is unknown eight years after entry (−0.49, 797 institutions, 2023–24, direction tier). Lower-priced publics tend to report more students who left without a known award or transfer.
  • Private nonprofits: the gap between the cost of attendance and the net price for families earning $30,001–48,000 moves with SAT math 25th-percentile scores (0.79, 580 institutions) and with six-year graduation rates (0.60, 1,111), and moves against the share of faculty who are part-time (−0.54, 1,027); all 2023–24, direction tier.

Some strong rows are close to arithmetic, so we do not count them as findings. Public net price moves with in-state tuition (0.70, 801 institutions), and the private gap moves with tuition (0.88, 1,153) and with the average grant (0.94, 1,152), all 2023–24, direction tier. Tuition is part of the cost of attendance, and the gap is mostly the grant. Within institutions, year-to-year changes in public net price from 2014–15 to 2023–24 show nothing beyond such arithmetic except rows where net price is preceded by board charges (0.20, 836 institutions) or by tuition (0.40, one Carnegie class), both at the exists tier, the lowest.

The earnings and out-of-state rows allow two readings. Higher-priced publics may compete in a national market for students who go on to earn more. Or wealth and selectivity may raise both price and later earnings. A comparison that controls for selectivity and family income would tell them apart. A single year’s cross-section cannot.

What the data cannot tell

  • How many students pay the full published price. IPEDS reports averages for aid recipients, not the share paying the sticker price.
  • Net price for out-of-state students at publics. IPEDS collects it for in-state students only.
  • Net price after 2022–23, or tuition after 2023–24. Those years were added to the warehouse after this post was written.
  • Graduate and returning students. Net price covers first-time, full-time undergraduates.
  • Where your institution sits. A median across hundreds of colleges is not a figure for one college.

What this means for planning

  • Read price growth against inflation year by year. A ten-year comparison ending in 2022 mixes years of tuition growth above inflation with two years of inflation above tuition growth.
  • Track the discount alongside the sticker price. At the median private nonprofit, institutional grants now exceed half of published tuition for first-year students.
  • Compare net price within each income band, and remember that the bands are not adjusted for inflation. A rising average can come from more families in the top band.
  • Put price next to local income and local prices before comparing with distant peers. A college in a low-cost place can look cheap in nominal dollars and not in local purchasing power.

Every figure here comes from public data: IPEDS, BEA, the Census American Community Survey and BLS CPI-U. In Academia Superiora you can run the same comparisons for your own peer group, free.

Next postRetention is at a twelve-year high. What is behind it