Academia Superiora

← All research

Data · IPEDS + BEA + Scorecard

Behind the rebound in first-time students

First-time students are back near their 2013 level, but the mix has changed. Recent high school graduates held flat, the South and West grew while the Northeast and Midwest shrank, and colleges now take far more applications for each student who enrolls.

October 12, 2026 · 9 min read

Dozens of small robed figures on the tiers of a stone amphitheater

Our review of the latest IPEDS data found that first-time, degree-seeking undergraduates fell from 3.22 million in fall 2013 to 2.75 million in fall 2020, then rose to 3.11 million in fall 2024. That leaves the national count 3.4% below 2013. This post takes that one number apart: by the age at which students enter, by sector, by the state they come from, and by what happened in admissions offices on the way.

Scope: first-time, degree- or certificate-seeking undergraduates, full- and part-time, as reported to the IPEDS Fall Enrollment survey by every institution that takes federal student aid. Fall 2013 is the 2013–14 collection. Counts by state of residence come from the Fall Enrollment residence file, which every institution must complete in even years, so those comparisons run from fall 2014 to fall 2024.

The rebound came more from students who did not just finish high school

IPEDS splits first-time students into those who finished high school in the previous 12 months and everyone else. The everyone-else group includes students who took a gap year, worked first, or came back as adults.

Recent high school graduates have barely moved. There were 2.29 million in fall 2014 and 2.30 million in fall 2024, a change of 0.5%. The other group fell from 859,000 in fall 2014 to 607,000 in fall 2020, then recovered to 811,000 in fall 2024. It is still 5.6% below 2014.

Between fall 2020 and fall 2024 first-time enrollment grew by 356,000. Recent graduates account for 153,000 of that. Students who did not finish high school in the past 12 months account for 203,000. The pandemic drop was also uneven: from fall 2018 to fall 2020 recent graduates fell 7.8%, and the other group fell 15.7%.

First-time, degree-seeking undergraduates by time since high school, fall, in millions
0.4M1.5M2.5M201420162018202020222024

Finished high school in the past 12 monthsAll other first-time students

Source: IPEDS Fall Enrollment, residence file (EF C), even years 2014–2024, all reporting institutions, all-states total line.

Two-year and four-year: the line itself moved

As institutions reported their sector each year, first-time students at public four-year institutions rose from 1.16 million in fall 2013 to 1.52 million in fall 2024 (+31.2%). At public two-year colleges they fell from 1.15 million to 0.80 million (−30.8%). Read at face value, that is a large shift of entering students from community colleges to universities.

Much of it is a change of label. Between 2013 and 2024, 140 public institutions that IPEDS classed as two-year in 2013 were classed as four-year in 2024, mostly because they began to award bachelor’s degrees. They enrolled 209,000 first-time students in fall 2013 and 221,000 in fall 2024. Mergers also move students between institution records.

First-time students at the 4,607 institutions that reported them in both fall 2013 and fall 2024, by sector as classified in 2013
Sector in 2013Fall 2013Fall 2024Change
Public four-year1,139,6071,276,166+12.0%
Private nonprofit four-year511,246530,916+3.8%
Public two-year1,110,1621,011,192−8.9%
For-profit, all levels154,538169,844+9.9%
Other (private nonprofit two-year and less-than-two-year, public less-than-two-year)29,74028,019−5.8%
All2,945,2933,016,137+2.4%

Held at their 2013 classification, public two-year colleges lost 8.9% of their first-time students and public four-year institutions gained 12.0%. The direction is the same as in the reported figures. The size is a third or less.

The same panel explains most of the gap between the national count and 2013. Institutions that reported first-time students in both years grew 2.4% together. The national total is 3.4% lower because of who reports. The 2,265 institutions that reported first-time students in fall 2013 but not in fall 2024 had 275,000 of them. The 781 that reported in fall 2024 but not in fall 2013 had 93,000. For-profit schools show this most clearly: as reported, their first-time students fell from 339,000 to 209,000 (−38.3%), while the for-profit schools that still report grew 9.9%.

The pandemic year hit community colleges hardest. As reported, public two-year colleges went from 928,000 first-time students in fall 2019 to 748,000 in fall 2020 (−19.4%). Public four-year institutions fell 3.9% and private nonprofit four-year institutions 5.5%.

Where students come from: the South and West grew

The residence file counts first-time students by the state they lived in when admitted, wherever they enrolled. Among residents of the 50 states and the District of Columbia (the national total above also counts foreign students and residents of US territories), recent high school graduates entering college rose 1.1% from fall 2014 to fall 2024. The regions went in opposite directions.

First-time students who finished high school in the past 12 months, by Census region of residence, and resident population
RegionFall 2014Fall 2024ChangePopulation change, 2014–2024Enrolled in another state, 2024
Northeast435,295399,879−8.1%+2.1%31.3%
Midwest485,398449,288−7.4%+2.2%22.1%
South788,939850,333+7.8%+10.9%16.7%
West471,416505,660+7.3%+6.6%17.7%
50 states and DC2,181,0482,205,160+1.1%+6.5%20.7%

The largest gains were in Idaho (+33.6%), Utah (+32.1%), Nevada (+23.6%) and Texas (+21.9%, from 188,000 to 229,000). The largest losses were in Vermont (−24.0%), Alaska (−18.2%), New Hampshire (−15.5%), Michigan (−15.1%) and Wisconsin (−13.8%). Pennsylvania fell 12.7% and New York 7.5%. California rose 3.4%.

We compared each state’s change with its population change from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Across the 51, states whose population grew faster also tended to send more recent graduates to college (Pearson r = 0.75, rank correlation 0.72). States whose per-capita personal income grew faster tended to as well, more weakly (r = 0.45), but income growth and population growth go together across states (r = 0.49). The level of per-capita income in 2024 showed almost no relationship with the change (r = 0.07). Across states, the change tracked population growth more closely than income growth or income level.

More students also cross state lines. The share of recent graduates enrolling outside their home state rose from 18.9% in fall 2014 to 20.7% in fall 2024. In the Northeast it is 31.3%. Vermont sends 60.5% of its entering students to other states and New Hampshire 50.0%. Utah, California and Texas keep all but 10% to 14% at home.

The state comparison is a cross-section of 51 changes over one decade, computed by us, not a row from our relationships table. BEA population counts all ages, not 18-year-olds. Income is nominal. A student enrolled online at an institution in another state counts as enrolled in that state.

The pool ahead is smaller. WICHE’s Knocking at the College Door (2024 edition) projects that the number of US high school graduates peaks around 2025 and then declines through 2041, with the steepest declines in the Northeast and Midwest. Those are the two regions where fewer recent graduates already enter college than in 2014.

More applications for each student who enrolls

Colleges that do not admit everyone report applications, admissions and enrolled first-time students to the IPEDS Admissions survey. We followed the 1,584 institutions that reported all three every fall from 2014 to 2024. Open-admission colleges, which include most community colleges, are not in it.

Admissions at 1,584 institutions that reported every fall, 2014–2024
MeasureFall 2014Fall 2024Change
Applications9.20M14.35M+56.1%
Admitted5.09M8.42M+65.6%
Enrolled first-time1.48M1.64M+11.1%
Admit rate55.3%58.7%+3.4 points
Yield (enrolled ÷ admitted)29.0%19.5%−9.5 points
Applications per enrolled student6.28.8+40%

Applications grew five times faster than enrollment. Admissions grew faster still, so the admit rate rose slightly. The result is a fall in yield: in 2014 colleges enrolled 29 of every 100 students they admitted, in 2024 fewer than 20. At the 499 public four-year institutions in the panel, applications rose 67.0%, enrolled students 13.7%, and yield fell from 32.4% to 20.3%. At the 951 private nonprofit four-year institutions, applications rose 42.5%, enrolled students 5.5%, and yield fell from 23.5% to 17.5%.

Selectivity sorts the pattern. The 66 institutions that admitted fewer than 25% of applicants in 2014 kept their yield close to where it was (46.4% to 44.3%) and enrolled 10.0% more students. Institutions that admitted 50% to 74% in 2014 raised their admit rate from 63.0% to 70.3%, and their yield fell from 27.8% to 17.9%. Those admitting 75% or more saw yield fall from 30.2% to 19.8%.

An application count is not a count of people. One student who applies to eight colleges is eight applications. Rates here are totals over the panel, so large institutions weigh more than small ones.

What moves with first-time enrollment

Our relationships table reads how two measures move together across institutions. Its change rows compare each institution’s year-to-year changes, with the change every institution shared in a given year removed. The rows below are all at the direction tier: the Pearson and rank coefficients agree in sign, and the same relationship holds in at least three cohort scopes. None of them says why.

  • First-time enrollment changes with the number admitted: coefficient 0.73 (rank 0.58), 19,360 institution-years at 2,452 institutions, 2015–2024, direction tier. It changes with the number of applications less closely: 0.62 (rank 0.45), same n and years, direction tier. At public four-year institutions the two are 0.58 and 0.44 (5,443 institution-years at 580 institutions, 2015–2024, direction tier). Enrolled students are part of admitted students, so some of the first link is arithmetic.
  • Applications change with yield, in opposite directions: coefficient −0.35 (rank −0.33), 17,454 institution-years at 2,423 institutions, 2015–2023, direction tier. In a year when an institution’s applications rise more than the year’s average, its yield tends to fall. At public four-year institutions the coefficient is −0.54 (rank −0.43; 4,898 institution-years at 579 institutions, 2015–2023, direction tier).
  • At public four-year institutions, in-state, on-campus cost of attendance moves against yield: size-adjusted coefficient −0.47 (rank −0.33), 542 institutions, fall 2023, direction tier.
  • At private nonprofit four-year institutions, the average net price for families earning $48,001 to $75,000 (College Scorecard) moves against yield: size-adjusted coefficient −0.38 (Pearson −0.43, rank −0.37), 1,018 institutions, fall 2023, direction tier.

The applications row fits two stories. Students may be applying to more places, so each application carries less intent to enroll. Or institutions that recruit more widely reach students who were always less likely to come. A test that would separate them: hold the number admitted steady and see whether yield still falls when applications rise. The price rows fit a price story and a wealth or selectivity story equally well, since cheaper and more selective institutions are not a random set.

The two price rows are one year, fall 2023, and we have not checked them in another year. A relationship across institutions in one year is not a trend, and it is not your institution.

What the data cannot tell

  • A college-going rate. IPEDS counts students who enrolled, not the high school graduates who could have. These counts are the numerator only.
  • Who did not enroll and why. The residence file has no record of a graduate who went to work, enlisted or waited.
  • Real competition between institutions. Applications are counted per institution, so a rise can mean more students or more applications per student.
  • The full community college picture. Open-admission colleges do not report applications, and high school students taking dual-enrollment courses are not first-time, degree-seeking undergraduates.
  • Online students’ location. A student who lives in Ohio and enrolls online at an institution in New Hampshire counts as leaving Ohio.

What this means for planning

  • Split your entering class into recent high school graduates and everyone else. Nationally the two groups have moved differently since 2014, and the rebound since 2020 leaned on the second.
  • Look at your feeder states’ residents, not only your own applicants. The residence file shows how many of each state’s graduates enter college and how many leave the state to do it.
  • Plan on yield and admits, not applications. On a stable panel, applications rose 56% and enrolled students 11%.
  • Compare sectors on a fixed classification. A community college that began awarding bachelor’s degrees moves its students into the four-year count.
  • In the Northeast and Midwest, assume the pool of recent graduates keeps shrinking, and weigh students who enter later.

Every figure here comes from public data: IPEDS, the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the College Scorecard. In Academia Superiora you can run the same comparisons for your own peer group, free.

Next postTuition kept pace with inflation. Net price fell behind it.